Independent Editorial · Not Affiliated With Any Studio or Streaming Service · Editorial Policy

Hallmark Hanukkah Movies Ranked by Reviews So Far

Round and Round (2023) ranks as the best Hallmark Hanukkah movie by reviews so far. Leah's Perfect Gift (2024) ranks last among ten films in the latest audience-score ranking. Hallmark Hanukkah movies are holiday romances built around Hanukkah traditions, family gatherings, and new relationships. The List reports the first was Hitched for the Holidays (2012), followed by more titles in 2019 and at least one Hanukkah film each year since.

Table of Contents

How the scores work

The List compares audience scores by averaging each film's weighted IMDb rating and Letterboxd rating into one 10-point score, according to The List's Hanukkah ranking method. That approach favors films liked across both audiences, not films with one strong score.

Ranks can move because IMDb and Letterboxd averages change as more viewers vote. Some titles also have very few critic reviews, so audience scores carry most of the weight.

Why does Round and Round lead?

Round and Round stars Vic Michaelis as Rachel, stuck reliving her parents' Hanukkah party in a time loop. It earned 88% on Rotten Tomatoes, 7.1/10 on IMDb, and 3.4/5 on Letterboxd, according to The List's all-time holiday ranking.

Collider also places Round and Round first among nine Hallmark Hanukkah movies, according to Collider's Hanukkah ranking. The time-loop structure gives it a clearer comic engine than a standard holiday romance.

Where do other titles land?

Hanukkah on Rye, released Dec. 18, 2022, follows matchmaker-paired Molly and Jacob, rival deli owners finding common ground. Rotten Tomatoes lists about 7.3/10 on IMDb and 73/100 from two critics.

Hitched for the Holidays sits ninth in Collider's nine-film ranking. Leah's Perfect Gift sits tenth in The List's ten-film audience ranking, with 6/10 on IMDb and 2.86/5 on Letterboxd for a 5.86/10 average. Different film counts explain the different last-place titles across lists.

How should you choose one to watch?

Recheck IMDb, Letterboxd, and Rotten Tomatoes before choosing because viewer votes shift averages. Brit.co notes catalog titles stream on Hallmark+, according to Brit.co's 2025 Hanukkah guide.

  • Pick Round and Round for comedy with a fantasy twist.
  • Pick Hanukkah on Rye for a food-centered romantic rivalry.
  • Pick Hitched for the Holidays for the earliest Hanukkah entry.
  • Pick Leah's Perfect Gift if you want the newest lower-ranked title.

You Might Also Like

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy.