Avatar: Fire and Ash Might Surprise Studios With Weak Pre-Sales
James Cameron’s third Avatar film is set to hit theaters on December 19, 2025, but early ticket sales numbers are raising eyebrows in the entertainment industry. While the numbers might sound impressive on the surface, they’re actually falling short of what studios expected based on the massive success of Avatar: The Way of Water.
The film began selling IMAX advance tickets last week, with bookings for other formats opening shortly after. Within just the first full day of sales across major cinema chains, Avatar: Fire and Ash had sold over 50,000 tickets for the opening weekend, generating more than 3 crore rupees in India alone. Overall weekend advance sales climbed past 4 crore rupees gross. On the surface, these numbers seem strong for a film that hasn’t even been released yet.
However, when compared to Avatar: The Way of Water, the gap becomes concerning. Avatar 2 had raked in over 12 crore rupees in pre-sales before its release. That’s nearly three times what Fire and Ash has managed so far, even accounting for the fact that Avatar 2 had a longer sales window. The difference is substantial enough that industry analysts are taking notice.
Why is there such a dramatic drop in pre-sales momentum? The answer lies in audience expectations and market saturation. Avatar: The Way of Water arrived after more than a decade of anticipation. The original Avatar was a cultural phenomenon that dominated the box office and became the highest-grossing film of all time. When Avatar 2 finally arrived in 2022, it carried the weight of that massive legacy and pent-up demand from fans who had been waiting since 2009.
Fire and Ash, by contrast, is arriving just three years after The Way of Water. While three years might seem like a long time between films, it’s remarkably short in the context of the Avatar franchise’s history. Audiences haven’t had years to build anticipation. The novelty of returning to Pandora hasn’t had time to fully develop. This is simply another Avatar film in a relatively short timeframe, rather than a long-awaited return to a beloved world.
This trend isn’t limited to India. Pre-sales are down compared to Avatar 2 across multiple markets worldwide. The pent-up demand that propelled Avatar 2 to such a massive head start simply isn’t present this time around. Studios are learning that even the most successful franchises can experience fatigue when entries arrive too frequently.
That said, there are reasons for cautious optimism. James Cameron is known for making bold statements about his films, famously advising people not to judge his movies until the third weekend of release. Advance sales are expected to pick up as the release date draws closer. The gap between first-day pre-sales numbers for the two films will likely narrow considerably before December 19 arrives.
Additionally, Fire and Ash has a significant advantage that Avatar 2 didn’t have in quite the same way: the holiday season. The film opens during the third weekend in December, the same timeframe as the original Avatar in 2009 and The Way of Water in 2022. The original Avatar held practically steady between its debut and Christmas the following weekend, dropping only 1.8 percent. This suggests that holiday moviegoing patterns could provide a substantial boost to Fire and Ash’s box office performance.
Industry forecasts are mixed but generally optimistic about the film’s overall performance. Some tracking suggests the film could open with between 95 million and 115 million dollars domestically. Other long-range forecasts predict that Avatar: Fire and Ash could actually exceed The Way of Water’s 134.1 million dollar opening. The film’s runtime of 3 hours and 15 minutes makes it the longest Avatar movie yet, suggesting Cameron has packed substantial content into this installment.
The weak pre-sales numbers tell an important story about franchise fatigue and audience expectations. Studios are learning that even the most powerful franchises need breathing room between installments. The massive success of Avatar 2 created unrealistic expectations for how quickly audiences would embrace a third film. Fire and Ash may ultimately perform well at the box office, but the early ticket sales suggest that the days of Avatar commanding the kind of immediate, overwhelming demand it once did may be behind it.
Sources
