What Is the Critic Score for Goodfellas on Metacritic

Goodfellas holds a critic score of 92 out of 100 on Metacritic, placing it in the “universal acclaim” category based on reviews from 21 professional critics.

This score, earned when Martin Scorsese’s 1990 gangster epic was first released and reviewed by the critical establishment, has remained stable over the decades as the film’s reputation has only solidified.

The 92 score reflects widespread critical agreement that Goodfellas is not just a good gangster film, but a transformative work in cinema history—a rare consensus in a medium where critics often sharply disagree about even canonical films.

This article explores what that score actually represents, how Metacritic arrived at it, and what it means for understanding both the film and the nature of critical reception itself.

We’ll examine how Goodfellas compares to other acclaimed films, what distinguishes a 92 from other scores in Metacritic’s range, and why this particular number has become such an important reference point for evaluating one of cinema’s most influential works.

Table of Contents

• How Does Goodfellas’ 92 Score Compare to Other Top-Rated Films?
• Understanding Metacritic’s Universal Acclaim Designation
• Why Has This Score Remained Stable Since 1990?
• How Do Critic Scores Differ From User Scores on Metacritic?
• What Does a 92 Score Actually Predict About Watching Goodfellas?
• The Critics’ Consensus on Goodfellas’ Achievement
• What Does Goodfellas’ Score Mean for Modern Film Criticism?
• Conclusion

How Does Goodfellas’ 92 Score Compare to Other Top-Rated Films?

A score of 92 on Metacritic places Goodfellas in the upper echelon of films ever reviewed on the platform. To put this in perspective, scores above 90 are genuinely rare—they represent films that achieved near-universal critical praise without significant dissent.

For comparison, The Godfather (1972) sits at 95, The Godfather Part II at 96, and 2001: A Space Odyssey at 84.

Goodfellas’ 92 places it above most other crime dramas and above many films now considered classics, yet slightly below the two Godfather films—a positioning that reflects the critical community’s view of where each film stands in the gangster genre hierarchy. The 21 critics whose reviews contributed to this score represents a substantial critical consensus.

Metacritic’s methodology requires reviews from established critics and publications, not crowd-sourced opinions, which means each voice on that 92 carries weight.

When a film reaches this threshold with this many critics, it typically means the reviews weren’t just positive—they were enthusiastically positive, with critics using language like “masterpiece,” “groundbreaking,” or “essential cinema.” The consistency across these 21 different critics from different publications with different aesthetic preferences makes the score particularly meaningful, as it wasn’t driven by a single critic’s passionate defense or a particular critical school’s preference.

Understanding Metacritic’s Universal Acclaim Designation

metacritic categorizes scores in distinct bands: 81-100 is “universal acclaim,” 61-80 is “generally favorable,” 40-60 is “mixed reviews,” and below 40 is “generally unfavorable.” Goodfellas sits comfortably within the universal acclaim band, but there’s an important caveat: not every film in this band is created equal.

A score of 81 and a score of 92 are both “universal acclaim,” yet they represent different degrees of critical consensus.

At 92, Goodfellas is in the top tier of the universal acclaim category, suggesting that the 21 critics didn’t just find the film good—they found it genuinely great with very few, if any, significant reservations.

However, it’s worth noting that Metacritic’s scoring system relies on critics’ existing review scores being converted to a 0-100 scale. This means the 92 isn’t an average of 21 critics all giving the same rating; rather, it’s a weighted average of different critical perspectives converted to a single number.

Some critics might have given Goodfellas a rave review, while others might have given it a strong positive review with minor quibbles. The 92 represents the consensus that emerged from averaging those different degrees of enthusiasm.

Why Has This Score Remained Stable Since 1990?

The remarkable fact about Goodfellas’ 92 score is that it hasn’t changed substantially since the film’s release. This stability reflects something important: unlike many films that gain or lose critical favor over decades, Goodfellas has maintained its critical status across generations of critics.

A film like Blade Runner was initially reviewed coolly by mainstream critics but has since been re-evaluated upward as its influence became apparent. Goodfellas experienced the opposite trajectory—it was instantly recognized as significant and has only become more respected with time.

The stability of this score matters because it suggests a kind of critical consensus that transcends any particular moment or critical fashion. The critics who reviewed Goodfellas in 1990 and contributed to the 92 score were responding to something that subsequent critics and filmmakers have continued to affirm.

Scorsese’s technique, the screenplay by Nicholas Pileggi, the performances by Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Ray Liotta—these elements haven’t diminished in retrospect. If anything, they’ve become more evident as the film’s influence on subsequent crime dramas and mob narratives has become clear.

How Do Critic Scores Differ From User Scores on Metacritic?

While Goodfellas holds a 92 critic score, it’s important to distinguish this from user scores, which operate on a separate track on Metacritic. The critic score is determined by professional reviewers; the user score is an aggregate of ratings submitted by regular viewers.

For Goodfellas, the user score is significantly lower than the critic score—a phenomenon that reveals how critics and audiences sometimes evaluate films differently. General audiences, while respecting Goodfellas as a classic, may rate it differently than critics who’re evaluating its technical craft, narrative structure, and historical significance.

This divergence isn’t unusual. Critics tend to weight factors like directorial technique, screenplay sophistication, and cultural impact more heavily, while casual viewers might prioritize entertainment value, pacing, or emotional resonance. A film can be both critically brilliant and challenging for mainstream audiences to fully appreciate on first viewing.

Goodfellas, with its rapid-fire editing, dense screenplay, and morally ambiguous protagonist, is a film that demands active attention from viewers—something critics are trained to provide, but not all casual viewers may seek.

What Does a 92 Score Actually Predict About Watching Goodfellas?

This is where a critical caveat must be inserted: a score of 92 doesn’t mean everyone will like Goodfellas, nor does it guarantee you’ll find it as revelatory as critics did. Metacritic scores are descriptive, not prescriptive—they tell you what professional critics thought, not whether you personally will enjoy the film.

Critics in 1990 were analyzing Goodfellas as a work of cinema art, considering its place in film history and its technical achievements.

If you’re watching it primarily to be entertained by a crime story, your experience might differ significantly from the critical evaluation embedded in that 92. Additionally, a 92 is based on reviews from three decades ago, written when Goodfellas was new and shocking to audiences.

Those critics couldn’t have known how influential the film would become, how many filmmakers would be inspired by its style, or how the gangster genre would evolve partly in response to what Scorsese accomplished.

The score reflects how critics felt in that moment, not a comprehensive evaluation of how the film has aged or how subsequent generations might assess it.

The Critics’ Consensus on Goodfellas’ Achievement

The 21 critics whose reviews contributed to the 92 score generally agreed on what made Goodfellas significant: its rejection of mythologizing the mob in favor of showing the mundane reality of criminal life, its technical innovation in editing and music selection, and its performances, particularly Joe Pesci’s volatile and terrifying portrayal of Tommy DeVito.

Where critics might have differed was on secondary matters—whether the film’s second half was quite as effective as the first, or whether some narrative choices were fully earned—but these differences didn’t substantially alter the consensus that Goodfellas was a major achievement.

The breadth of critical agreement is notable because Goodfellas isn’t a conservative or traditional film.

It’s violent, profane, morally murky, and structurally unconventional. That nearly two dozen critics from different critical traditions and publications could agree on its greatness suggests the film transcends particular critical preferences. It works not just for formalist critics interested in technique, but for narrative-focused critics, character study advocates, and those evaluating cultural significance.

What Does Goodfellas’ Score Mean for Modern Film Criticism?

In an era where Metacritic has become a primary reference point for evaluating films—influencing studio decisions, affecting theatrical runs, and shaping audience expectations—Goodfellas’ 92 score serves as a kind of north star.

It’s one of the highest scores on the platform, which means it’s frequently cited as a standard against which other crime dramas and contemporary films are measured.

Filmmakers making gangster stories are implicitly responding to the success and critical consensus around Goodfellas, whether they’re trying to match it, subvert it, or move beyond it entirely.

The stability and prominence of this score also highlights something important about Metacritic’s role in film culture: it has become a permanent archive of critical reception, creating a historical record of what critics thought at the moment a film was released.

For younger audiences discovering Goodfellas now, the 92 score carries weight because it’s not a modern re-evaluation—it’s evidence that critics decades ago recognized the film’s greatness, which lends credibility to recommendations in a way that contemporary scores cannot.

Conclusion

Goodfellas’ critic score of 92 on Metacritic, based on reviews from 21 professional critics, represents one of the highest critical evaluations of any film, indicating universal acclaim and near-universal agreement among critics that the film is a masterpiece.

This score has remained stable for over three decades, reflecting the film’s enduring status in cinema history rather than a temporary critical fashion or a delayed recognition of its merits. The 92 isn’t just a number—it’s evidence of a critical consensus that transcended different critical perspectives and publications when the film was released.

Understanding what that score represents—and what it doesn’t—helps viewers contextualize Goodfellas within film history and approach it with appropriate expectations. The score reflects critics’ evaluation of the film’s technical achievement, narrative innovation, and cultural significance.

If you’re planning to watch Goodfellas for the first time, the 92 indicates that you’re about to see something widely regarded as great cinema, though your personal response may differ from the critical consensus.

The film’s influence on subsequent crime dramas and its continued relevance in discussions of American cinema confirm that the critics who contributed to that score were evaluating something genuinely significant.

---

You Might Also Like

• What Is the Critic Score for Schindler’s List on Metacritic
• What Is the Critic Score for Pulp Fiction on Metacritic
• What Is the Critic Score for Inception on Metacritic

Browse more: Box Office | Entertainment | Film | Movie News | Movies

For more on Critic Score Goodfellas, see the full breakdown above – the critic score goodfellas details cover what most viewers want to know.

Whether you searched for critic score goodfellas reviews, critic score goodfellas streaming, or critic score goodfellas cast, this guide consolidates the relevant critic score goodfellas facts in one place.