The pivotal twist in *Sex and the City 2* centers on Carrie Bradshaw’s chance encounter with her ex-boyfriend Aidan Shaw in an Abu Dhabi spice market, where they kiss—a transgression that becomes the film’s emotional turning point. Rather than hide the infidelity, Carrie confesses to Mr. Big, choosing honesty over deception.
Big’s response redefines their marriage: he presents her with a striking 5-carat black diamond engagement ring, a gesture that transforms the betrayal into a moment of recommitment and individual recognition within their relationship. The twist operates on multiple levels—it tests Carrie’s fidelity, Big’s security, and the couple’s ability to move past temptation through transparency. What makes it effective is that it doesn’t end in traditional punishment or forgiveness. Instead, the black diamond becomes a tangible symbol of their relationship’s uniqueness, suggesting that their bond can absorb and survive this collision with Carrie’s past.
Table of Contents
- The Unexpected Reunion and the Kiss That Changes Everything
- The Black Diamond Ring—Design, Symbolism, and Real-World Rarity
- Abu Dhabi and the Souk—Where the Twist Unfolds
- The Secondary Twist—The Dior Gowns Beneath the Burkas
- How the Confession Reveals Carrie’s Growth
- The Real-World Significance of Black Diamond Engagement Rings
- The Ring as a Turning Point in Film Narrative
The Unexpected Reunion and the Kiss That Changes Everything
Carrie’s encounter with Aidan happens organically during the group’s exploration of Abu Dhabi’s markets. The two lock eyes across the sensory chaos of the souk—vendors calling out, spices stacked in towering displays, tourists and locals moving through narrow passages. It’s a moment designed to feel like fate, though the film frames it as temptation. Aidan, still carrying the weight of their unfinished relationship, invites her to dinner. At dinner, the conversation drifts into dangerous territory.
Carrie admits to her recent marital struggles with Big, describing a marriage that has begun to feel static despite its outward stability. Aidan listens with the ease of someone who once knew her intimately, and when they kiss, it reads less as malice and more as a moment of lost gravity—two people reverting to a version of themselves that no longer exists. This is different from a calculated affair; it’s the collision of nostalgia with present dissatisfaction. Carrie’s choice to confess rather than conceal becomes the real turning point. She faces Big that night and tells him everything, knowing that secrecy would corrode their marriage far more than the kiss itself.
The Black Diamond Ring—Design, Symbolism, and Real-World Rarity
When Mr. big learns of the kiss, he doesn’t respond with anger. Instead, he removes Carrie’s original engagement ring and replaces it with a show-stopping piece: a 5-carat black diamond surrounded by 80 round natural colorless pavé diamonds, all set in 18-karat white gold. The ring was designed by Itay Malkin, a jewelry designer known for high-end custom pieces. In real terms, a black diamond of this carat weight and quality is exceptionally rare—black diamonds appear in fewer than 1% of all diamond finds, and they command premium prices precisely because of their scarcity and the challenge of cutting them properly.
Big’s accompanying statement—”Because you are not like anyone else”—reframes the ring’s meaning. Rather than a peace offering or a bribe, it becomes a declaration that their marriage is built on Carrie’s individuality, not conformity. The black diamond itself symbolizes something unconventional and rare, mirroring Carrie’s nature. However, a limitation worth noting: black diamonds are significantly less common than colorless diamonds in jewelry, which means insuring, resizing, or repairing such a ring requires specialists. Unlike a standard diamond, a black diamond’s durability is slightly lower (7 on the Mohs hardness scale versus 10 for colorless diamonds), making it more susceptible to scratching and chipping in daily wear. The symbolism is powerful, but the practical reality is that this ring requires more careful maintenance than a traditional engagement ring.
Abu Dhabi and the Souk—Where the Twist Unfolds
The film sets the twist sequence in Abu Dhabi’s spice markets, though the production actually filmed in Morocco due to filming permit restrictions in the United Arab Emirates. The souk setting is crucial—it’s a space of abundance, exoticism, and sensory overload, a contrast to the sterile modern interiors of Big and Carrie’s Manhattan life. The marketplace becomes a character itself: a place where Carrie feels alive again, where she’s not Mrs. Big but simply Carrie, the woman who gets lost in crowds and pursues impulse.
Aidan’s presence in Abu Dhabi feels almost incidental to the story until they collide. He’s working in the region, suggesting a life continued elsewhere without her. This proximity—running into someone you once planned to marry—amplifies the emotional weight. The souk’s narrow pathways and crowded texture mirror Carrie’s internal confusion; she’s surrounded by people but alone in her desire and doubt.
The Secondary Twist—The Dior Gowns Beneath the Burkas
Running parallel to Carrie’s kiss is a secondary reveal that illustrates the film’s central tension about femininity, expression, and cultural conformity. Early in their Abu Dhabi stay, the women in Carrie’s group are chased by local authorities for wearing revealing clothing. They’re rescued by a group of women in full burkas who lead them to safety. In a revelatory scene, these women remove their coverings to expose expensive, meticulously tailored Dior gowns underneath—luxury fashion that contradicts the initial appearance of modesty.
This moment encapsulates the film’s (often criticized) approach to cultural commentary: the suggestion that beneath layers of tradition lies Western luxury and glamour. Whether or not this moment works as social commentary, it functions narratively as a mirror to Carrie’s own duality—the gap between her public role as a devoted wife and her private desire. Just as the women in burkas conceal designer gowns, Carrie conceals her vulnerability and temptation beneath the identity of Mrs. Big.
How the Confession Reveals Carrie’s Growth
The twist’s most significant element is Carrie’s choice to confess rather than conceal. In the first *Sex and the City* film, Carrie faced a similar moment—hesitation at the altar—and chose to run. Here, she runs toward confrontation instead. Her confession to Big demonstrates that she’s chosen maturity over self-protection, even knowing the revelation could destroy her marriage. This is not the Carrie who rewrites her life in her column; this is the Carrie who accepts her actions and their consequences.
Big’s response—neither rage nor forgiveness, but understanding—suggests that their marriage has evolved beyond the conventional betrayal narrative. He doesn’t need her to be perfect; he needs her to be honest. The black diamond ring becomes a mutual statement: I see you, flaws and all, and I choose you anyway. This recalibration of their relationship is what allows the twist to land emotionally. Without the confession, it would be infidelity. With it, it becomes a test of intimacy.
The Real-World Significance of Black Diamond Engagement Rings
After *Sex and the City 2* was released in 2010, black diamond engagement rings experienced a surge in popularity, particularly among buyers seeking something distinctive. Carrie’s ring, designed by Itay Malkin, became a reference point for high-end custom jewelry. Black diamonds are mined primarily in Brazil and Central Africa, and their formation differs from colorless diamonds—many black diamonds result from intense irradiation in nature, which gives them their opaque, dark appearance.
For practical engagement ring buyers, a black diamond presents both appeal and challenge. The visual impact is undeniable; it photographs dramatically and stands apart from conventional rings. However, the rarity means custom design is often necessary, adding expense. Additionally, black diamonds can appear dull if poorly cut, requiring specialized craftsmanship to achieve the lustrous finish seen in Carrie’s ring.
The Ring as a Turning Point in Film Narrative
The black diamond ring functions as a plot device that closes one chapter of Carrie and Big’s relationship and opens another. Unlike traditional movie jewelry moments where a ring symbolizes the beginning of love, this ring marks a moment of recommitment after rupture. It’s a rare instance in romantic film where the climactic gesture doesn’t come at the start of a relationship but at its midpoint, when the real work of staying together begins.
The specificity of Itay Malkin’s design—the choice of black rather than colorless, the pavé diamonds arranged in contrast, the 18-karat white gold—matters because it distinguishes this ring from every other engagement ring worn in cinema. It’s not interchangeable; it’s definitively Carrie’s because it’s unconventional. In that way, the ring reinforces Big’s stated reason for giving it: a recognition that Carrie exists outside conventional categories, and that their marriage will too.
- —
